Review of: What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments
Michael Dicker
11/08/2021
Verified Buyer
238 (What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I) - good course on basics of DOE. Perhaps some amplification of Latin square Design using real case as opposed to hypothetical scenario would be useful. Thank you.
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Richard W. Job
07/07/2020
Multiple issues:
The text on p-25 says Figure illustrates---; there is no Figure 8 , it is Figure 9.
Tables 7 and 8 have the names reversed.
Exan question 5 states "testing ca serve---", . . . You are splitting hairs.
Exam question 7 statement is . . .
Exam question 14c you say the answer is . . .
Exam question 20, I will simply say the text in the course and the question as asked and answers leave me confused.
Exam question 26 the example left me confuses in that it is a 5X5 square experiment when in the text you specifically say the Latin Square design is a 4X4.
Exam question 28 is a symatics issue in that in the text on p 28 you call the test an F ratio rather than the F test which it is. I assumed it was not the F distribution.
Portions of the reviewers comments have been removed because they discuss the answers to test questions.
1 of 1 customers found this helpful.
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Engineer from Greenville
12/31/2019
Verified Buyer
Good post graduate course. After attempting this course numerous times I capitulate in failure to understand or successfully respond to tricky questions developed from superfluous phraseology and equations. It yields a minimum to any practical knowledge.
1 of 1 customers found this helpful.
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Paul B Jordan
12/31/2018
Verified Buyer
good learning and easy to use
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Steven B Kushnick, PE
07/17/2018
I'm sorry, but I found this course to be more of a handbook of statistics rather than instruction about the design and analysis of engineering experiments. The course assumes that the reader is well versed in statistics, and thus refers to variables that are not defined in the text, and statistical concepts that are not explained in the text. If you don't already know the course material, then learning the material from this course is difficult. I think that this course would be valuable to people with Statistical Process Control training, or with advanced statistical classroom learning. Such people will appreciate the handbook-like organization of the text, and will likely refer to the text in their work for years to come. But for those who are interested in the mechanics of designing and analyzing more effective experiments on engineering systems, I would suggest picking a different course.
4 of 4 customers found this helpful.
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Walter David Bruce
01/14/2018
Verified Buyer
This was a good, thorough course. One suggestion for improvement would be to add a discussion of the use of Minitab or other software in the use of ANOVA and factorial experiment design.
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Walter David Bruce
01/05/2018
Verified Buyer
Course 283- What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments 1 is a good course; however, it needs improvement. Addition of a table of nomenclature and additional solved problems that include numerical values would be helpful.
1 of 1 customers found this helpful.
Was this helpful?
283-What Every Engineer Should Know About the Design and Analysis of Engineering Experiments I
Daniel Nord
10/24/2017
Verified Buyer
Generally good. Could have had more user friendly explanation of symbols and nomenclature.
Was this helpful?